Category: Restaurant history

  • Greenhouse Grille Fayetteville: a history, 2006 to 2018

    Greenhouse Grille Fayetteville: a history, 2006 to 2018

    In short: Greenhouse Grille was a farm-to-table restaurant in Fayetteville, Arkansas, opened on Memorial Day 2006 by Jerrmy Gawthrop and Clayton Suttle. Known for “Conscious Cuisine”, local farm suppliers and green practices, it moved to 481 South School Avenue in the Mill District around 2009 and hosted live music. It was sold to Arsaga’s in 2018.

    Few small restaurants leave as long a shadow as Greenhouse Grille. It started with about $40,000 and a do-it-yourself remodel, became a regional symbol of local food, gave birth to a music festival and still appears on lists of the Fayetteville restaurants people miss most. This guide tells its story using the reporting and archived pages listed at the end. Greenhouse Table is an independent guide; it is not the restaurant and has no connection to its former owners.

    What was Greenhouse Grille?

    Greenhouse Grille was a casual Fayetteville restaurant built around local, organic and seasonal food. Its archived website called its cooking “Conscious Cuisine” and, in 2017, stated its mission as “to create and nourish a conscious community”. In food writing, a farm-to-table restaurant is one that buys much of its food directly from nearby farms and builds its menu around what they grow; our guide to what farm to table means covers the term in detail.

    The restaurant was also known as a green restaurant, meaning one that tries to cut its environmental impact through energy, waste and sourcing choices. Its archived “green attributes” page listed composting, recycling, LED lighting, on-site organic gardens and waste oil recycled into biodiesel, practices we explain in our guide to sustainable restaurant practices.

    A small casual dining room with mismatched wooden tables and plants in the windows
    The first Greenhouse Grille seated about 50 people. Illustration.

    The 2006 opening

    Talk Business & Politics profiled the restaurant in June 2007, a year after it opened on Memorial Day 2006. Owners Jerrmy Gawthrop and Clayton Suttle told the magazine they started with about $40,000, remodelled the building themselves and opened with about 50 seats. Sales were running at about $35,000 a month.

    The details showed the approach. The restaurant served filtered water, sent its used fryer grease to be turned into fuel for cars and bought free-range chicken from Berryville, Arkansas. “We haven’t turned down a local farmer yet,” one owner told the magazine. The Arkansas Times reported in 2013 that there had been a line out the door on the first day.

    Wooden crates of fresh vegetables and greens stacked by a restaurant kitchen door
    The owners said they had never turned down a local farmer. Illustration.

    Greenhouse Grille Fayetteville: the move to the Mill District

    By 2009 the restaurant had outgrown its first home. Talk Business & Politics reported in June 2009 that Greenhouse Grille was moving into the former Wilma’s space in Fayetteville’s Mill District, in part to host live music. The restaurant’s archived home page from January 2010 describes the new home at 481 South School Avenue, at the corner of Highway 71B and Martin Luther King Jr Boulevard, beside the Frisco Trail, with twice the space and two stages.

    The same archived page said the restaurant was now neighbours with a Thursday evening farmers market. In November 2009 Talk Business reported that at least 40 percent of its food was organic year round, rising to as much as 70 percent at the peak of the season. The owners admitted some compromises: sweet potato fries stayed on the menu, they said, because you have to “pick your battles”.

    Greenhouse Grille at a glance

    ItemDetail
    OpenedMemorial Day 2006
    FoundersJerrmy Gawthrop and Clayton Suttle
    Second home481 S School Ave, Mill District, from about 2009 to 2010
    Organic shareAt least 40 percent year round, up to 70 percent in season (2009)
    Awards listedNWA Business Journal Greenest Business 2008; Sierra Club recognition 2008 to 2010
    SoldTo Arsaga’s, 2018
    A small outdoor music stage with string lights beside a brick restaurant at dusk
    The Mill District building had room for two music stages. Illustration.

    Farmers, awards and the food movement

    The restaurant’s archived pages listed its local providers and its awards: the NWA Business Journal’s 2008 Greenest Business Award for firms with fewer than 50 employees, and “Greenest Small Business” and “Greenest Restaurant” awards from the Sierra Club of Arkansas in 2008, 2009 and 2010. Talk Business reported in 2014 that Adams’ Acres was among the farms supplying it, as part of a wider “High South” food culture emerging in northwest Arkansas.

    In February 2013 the Arkansas Times ran a cover story titled “Greenhouse Grille gets it”, borrowing a phrase about writer Michael Pollan’s ideas and calling the restaurant a “locus of the food movement” in the region. It described hoop houses used to grow produce and plans to expand to Bentonville. The Fayetteville Farmers Market, a few blocks away, was part of the same local food scene.

    A plastic-covered hoop house with rows of young greens growing inside
    The restaurant grew some of its own produce. Illustration.

    Music and the Roots Festival

    The stages mattered. NWA Democrat-Gazette reported in 2020 that the first Fayetteville Roots Festival, in 2010, was a one-day event at Greenhouse Grille, started by Gawthrop with musicians Bryan and Bernice Hembree. It grew into a multi-day festival and nonprofit, a story told in our history of the Fayetteville Roots Festival.

    A slice of rustic fruit pie on a plain plate beside a cup of coffee on a wooden table
    A Greenhouse Grille pie recipe lives on in a cookbook. Illustration.

    The sale and what came after

    The restaurant changed hands in 2018. Only in Arkansas reports that Greenhouse Grille was sold to Arsaga’s, the Fayetteville coffee company, in 2018, and that Arsaga’s Mill District opened in the old building in October 2020. The Arkansas Times reported in 2018 that writer Kat Robinson’s new cookbook included a Greenhouse Grille pie recipe, after the restaurant had closed. KUAF reported that Arsaga’s Mill District itself closed in October 2025, after four years.

    Gawthrop talked about the sale and the festival on the I Am Northwest Arkansas podcast. The Fayetteville Flyer included Greenhouse Grille in its 2020 list of the most-missed restaurants in the city’s history.

    Key takeaways

    • Greenhouse Grille opened in Fayetteville on Memorial Day 2006 on a budget of about $40,000.
    • Founders Jerrmy Gawthrop and Clayton Suttle built it around local farms and green practices.
    • It moved to 481 S School Ave in the Mill District around 2009 and added two music stages.
    • The first Fayetteville Roots Festival was held there in 2010.
    • The restaurant was sold to Arsaga’s in 2018.

    Common questions

    Is Greenhouse Grille still open?

    No. The restaurant was sold to Arsaga’s in 2018, according to Only in Arkansas. Arsaga’s Mill District opened in the building in October 2020 and closed in October 2025, KUAF reported. There is no Greenhouse Grille operating today.

    Where was Greenhouse Grille in Fayetteville?

    From around 2009 it was at 481 South School Avenue in the Mill District, at the corner of Highway 71B and Martin Luther King Jr Boulevard beside the Frisco Trail. Before that it was in a smaller, 50-seat space, which the 2007 reporting does not locate precisely.

    Who founded Greenhouse Grille?

    Jerrmy Gawthrop and Clayton Suttle opened the restaurant on Memorial Day 2006, according to Talk Business & Politics. Gawthrop later co-founded the Fayetteville Roots Festival with Bryan and Bernice Hembree.

    Is this website Greenhouse Grille?

    No. Greenhouse Table is an independent guide to farm-to-table dining and Fayetteville food history. It has no connection with the restaurant, its founders or Arsaga’s, and does not take bookings or sell anything.

    How we put this together: the opening, budget and suppliers come from Talk Business & Politics in 2007 and 2009; the address, stages and awards come from archived copies of the restaurant’s own website; the 2013 profile comes from the Arkansas Times; the sale and later history come from Only in Arkansas, KUAF and the Arkansas Times.

    Sources